Where to live?

Hi friends! I’ve reviewed this sub so please don’t yell at me but I wanted to solicit everyone’s opinion based on my preferences.

I currently live on the west coast and want to make the trek back east within the next year or so - I’m originally from the Middletown area but am currently looking at relocating within an hour of Syracuse.

Here’s my ideal wishlist:

Cabin/cabin-like property Secluded At least 5 acres

Near breweries

Near outdoor recreation opportunities - lakes, mountain biking, hunting, etc.

Within an hour or so of Syracuse or a larger city that has concerts, sports, Costco

Small town feel close to the house, Gilmore Girls-esque where I can find a local diner/bar/etc. to frequent that is close

I put in a few offers on properties near Florence and Camden but got outbid - maybe for good reason because I have literally 0 idea what those areas are like. I’m open to pretty much anywhere in central NY.

Thank you for the help!