Decision time. Thoughts on these two options?

Rolex fam, I put my name in last month for a 2 tone GMT and a 2 tone Sky Dweller with Jubilee. My AD called (and then text) me while was as the movies to say he has the SD for me and to stop by today. I also found a 2005 Day Datewith a silver dial. Different watches, but they both speak to me for different reasons. I modern, most complicated and means business. The other timeless classic beauty.

My daily is the original Yacht Master with the platinum bezel that I got 17 years ago.

Thoughts?