Bills toe theory: Bill was never gay

Bills toe theory: Bill was never gay

For years, fans of Red Dead Redemption 2 have speculated about Bill Williamson’s sexuality, citing his dishonorable discharge from the army for "deviancy" as evidence that he may be gay. However, what if we've all been looking at this the wrong way? What if Bill wasn't interested in men but toes? I am 100% serious so hear me out, but keep in mind it’s just a theory.

This theory suggests that Bill Williamson has an intense, secretive fascination with toes, and that this fetish was the real reason for his discharge from the military. The U.S. Army wasn’t exactly understanding of "unconventional interests" at the time, and when Bill was caught rubbing a fellow soldier's foot in his sleep, it led to his immediate removal. But Bill’s interest in toes didn’t end there—it followed him into the Van der Linde gang.

Toe-Related Camp Interactions Throughout RDR2, Bill exhibits several peculiar behaviors that align with this theory. Here are a few overlooked camp interactions and dialogues that support the idea: * Pearson’s Complaints:If the player lingers near Pearson’s butcher table, he can sometimes be heard muttering:“I swear, someone keeps cuttin’ the toes off the carcasses… this ain’t normal.”This suggests that Bill has been sneaking into the supplies to collect animal toes for unknown reasons. * Arthur and Bill’s Argument:If Arthur antagonizes Bill repeatedly, he may say:"At least I don’t go ‘round starin’ at folks’ boots like a damn weirdo!"This line, which many players overlook, is a direct nod to Bill’s obsession. * Kieran’s Discomfort:Kieran, who is often bullied by Bill, has unique dialogue if the player approaches him at night:“He just stares at my feet… won’t say a word… it’s downright unsettlin’.”This disproves the theory that Bill had romantic feelings for Kieran—he was simply fixated on his toes. * Mary-Beth’s Observations:Mary-Beth, one of the more observant members of the gang, can occasionally be heard whispering to Tilly:“Did you see how Bill looked at that man’s feet in Valentine? I think he got distracted mid-fight… almost dreamy-eyed.”

The Toe Pouch and Toe Necklace Bill’s obsession doesn’t stop at mere admiration. Evidence suggests that he secretly collects severed toes, keeping them in a hidden pouch. This is hinted at in an unused gang camp robbery scenario found in the game files, where Arthur and Charles are supposed to stumble upon Bill’s tent at night. While the cutscene never made it into the final game, dataminers have uncovered voice lines from Charles saying: "What the hell is this, Bill? This some kinda sick joke?" Arthur’s response: "Jesus… them’s human toes, Bill. I don’t even wanna know." Though this scene was scrapped, its existence hints at Bill’s disturbing secret. The theory further suggests that Bill wears a toe necklace, made from both animal and possibly human toes, hidden beneath his clothing. If you inspect Bill closely in certain cutscenes, you can sometimes see a string poking out from under his collar, suggesting the presence of the forbidden necklace.

Conclusion: The Toe Truth While Bill Williamson is often dismissed as a loud-mouthed, violent drunk, the evidence suggests that his true obsession lies in toes. His dishonorable discharge, his eerie camp interactions, his mysterious "toe pouch," and the alleged scrapped content all point toward a shocking reality: Bill Williamson isn’t gay.