Black myth wukong or alan wake 2?

I’ve been trying to figure out what to gift my fiancé on his birthday and have zeroed in on these two games. About him: he has been playing PS since middle school. He plays story based games only and his favourite game is Uncharted. He loves God of war, Red dead redemption, GTA. Which one do you think he might like? Or any other game that you’d suggest which is available in India?