Looking for books that are completely unpredictable

Thanks to ADHD and pretty strong pattern recognition, I've found that I have an uncanny ability to call twists before they happen. This doesn't really take away my enjoyment of horror books because it's not usually about plot twists for me. But, I do find that my favorite books are ones that I read and have absolutely no idea where they're going.

I took a little horror break to read some fantasy novels on my shelf, but I'm looking to jump back into horror soon, so I'd appreciate some recommendations for what to pick up next!