Which bag should I keep?

A few days back, I posted about my micro zipped Bayswater. Then I saw mini Alexa on sale and ordered it to decide in person. Both are in Mulberry green shade. For some reason, the same color looks more vibrant on the leather of Alexa, but I prefer how it looks muted on Bayswater. Bayswater is definitely smaller in size, but I can still fit my phone. The leather on Alexa is softer and has larger grains. The hardware on Alexa is champagne gold compared to the deep gold hardware on Bayswater. Alexa is heavier and feels more substantial overall, but I really like the clean look of Bayswater. Alexa looks better as a crossbody on my body shape, but Bayswater is such a classic shape. I really can’t decide between the two. On sale, Alexa was approximately CA$300 more than Bayswater.