Al Nashama Caprice and Liam Grey smells are very similar !!

I received Liam Grey a couple of days ago, but I haven’t macerated it yet. I also have a macerated bottle of Al Nashama Caprice that’s been sitting for a couple of months.

To my inexperienced nose, they smell very similar, but Liam Grey feels much weaker compared to Al Nashama Caprice.

Does anyone else own both and can share their thoughts on how they compare?

Should I consider returning Liam grey?