Help me choose a watch for my bf!

Hi everyone! My boyfriend is not a very big watch guy but, he did state he's really been wanting one lately and from what I've read online Casio is a good start. I don't know much about watches myself but I found 2 options that I think suit him and he would like. I'm in a dilemma because the first (MTP1384D) one is beautiful and I can't seem to find it anywhere except this one guy who sells watches that used to be like those "demonstration models" in stores. The other one (MTP1381L) I like a little less but it is brand new. What do y'all think would be best?