Which Assassin's Creed gets a good reputation currentlythat you feel doesn't deserve it?

My best example here at least for me is Assassin's Creed Rogue. I've noticed recently with most media franchises that entries that are poorly reviewed at launch get looked back on incredibly fondly later and the reputation changes. My theory is that it's because people who first picked up the franchise around that time get older and then nostalgia blinds them. But nowhere does that seem more obvious to me than Rogue.

Rogue is a fun game in terms of gameplay, the gadgets are fun and it's an incredible time period being set during the seven years war. However, the story just sucks and half of what makes the game fun is only caused by the fact that it's essentially Black Flag. My main gripe is really with the story though. Shay is an incredibly boring protagonist and his turn is comically childish. The assassins don't even know or state that they intend to continue intentionally sinking cities. Everything the assassins actually do wrong in the game just seems comically out of character for the organization. It portrays them as all powerful at this time and extremely corrupt and felt like an intentional character assassination to try to make shay likable. And more than all of that, the death of adewale just kind of pissed me off and didn't feel earned. I'm sure there's other stuff I'm not thinking of and I know a lot of people think it's underrated now. But in my mind it really did mark a turn in the franchise for the worse and the story could have been handled so much more compellingly and nuanced for a game trying to portray the templar's side of the story.

So for you guys, what's a game in the franchise that feels the same for you?