Indy Evo's Won't Pair together.

I have tried absolutely EVERYTHING I could find and nothing seems to work. I've reset them, I've cleared them and put them in the case, and taken them back out, forgot the devices on my phone, looked on this Reddit page. I'm just lost.

When I take out the left one, it just doesn't pair. If I reset them, take them out, and let them pair to each other, they just go right to regular pairing. Both earbuds show up on my phone no matter what I do. I'm so incredibly frustrated. I haven't even owned them for 48 Hours.