Worthy gift?

Sons of Vulkan,

As my brother is one of you and has been asking me for a custom hatchet, I decided to build him a Salamanders themed one. Would you consider this a worthy gift?

Build info: The butt of the hatchet was filed into a hammer, the beard was profiled more aggressively, the blade was reprofiled and sharpened, the handle was charred on top and dyed green on the bottom, and both the handle guard and sheath were made from alligator and veg tan leather.