Hadestown or & Juliet??

Hello everyone, newbie to Broadway here. I’m looking to take my gf to a broadway show as a valentines present and can’t decide between Hadestown or & Juliet. From everything I’ve read Hadestown seems like the better piece of art and & Juliet is more lighthearted fun.

I’m leaning towards & Juliet since it’s a Valentine’s Day present and it’s supposed to be a more lighthearted show (and this will be our first broadway show). Is this a good or bad decision? Any input is appreciated!!